Friday, 28 June 2013

Karate punching is like swimming...


Image from:
https://www.boundless.com/
physics/the-laws-of-motion/
newton-s-laws/
the-third-law-symmetry-in-forces/
How many times has your sensei told you that the power of your punch should originate from the ground? That you draw power from the ground and then transmit it up your legs, through the hips and torso and down your arm. You believe him/her because you respect them, they have years more experience than you and they can punch harder than you (and you should believe them because it’s basically true) but you can’t quite get your head around why it should be true.

Drawing power from the ground gives karate a mystical, magical quality as if Mother Nature herself is giving you some ‘power assist’. If, like me, you tend to prefer more rational explanations then it’s easy to think that drawing energy from the ground sounds like twaddle.  But it isn't twaddle; it can be explained by the laws of physics.

I have recently been privileged to have a sneak preview of John Cole’s excellent book chapter on forces called ‘Push and pull explains all techniques’. I don’t want to pre-empt anything John has to say on this topic before his book is published but suffice to say he mentions Newton’s third law of motion which states: Every action has an equal and opposite reaction.  If we apply this law to people then basically, when you apply a force to an object it responds by applying and equal amount of force back to you. You transmit some of your energy into the object (e.g. by pushing it), the object transmits an equal amount of energy back into you.  What happens to that energy once it comes back to you depends on several factors: if you happen to be the smaller, lighter object then you will probably move; if you are not able to move freely, you’re restrained in some way, or the returned energy is being transmitted to a small surface area (e.g. you pricked your finger on a needle) then the energy may cause injury to you instead or alternatively you may be able to utilise the returned energy in some other way.

In my title I said that karate punching is like swimming. More specifically ‘drawing energy from the ground’ is analogous to pushing yourself away from the side of the swimming pool to gain momentum. If you can swim then you will know from experience that it is quicker to get some speed up if you push yourself away from the side of the pool with your feet than to just start swimming from a standing start. Why is this? Newton’s third law of motion explains it…..you push against the wall of the pool, transmitting energy into it and the pool wall ‘pushes’ an equal amount of energy back to you in the opposite direction. Since you are in a horizontal position in the pool (and you are weightless in water) the effect of receiving the energy back is to propel you in a forward direction.

A karate punch works on the same principle. If you take a firm stance and push down into the ground with your feet, transmitting energy into it, the ground responds by pushing an equal amount of energy back into you. Since you are in a vertical position the energy is transmitted upwards (opposite to the direction you pushed in). Though you are lighter than the ground below you the effects of gravity pressing down on you make it unlikely that you will respond by launching upwards (unless the ground below you was a trampoline!) The received energy doesn't normally injure you either because it is spread over the relatively large surface area of your feet (It might hurt more if you just pushed the ground with the top of your big toe) Instead, you are in a position to utilise that returning energy to enhance your punch.  How you achieve that is worthy of a blog or two of its own; suffice to say that with the correct sequence of muscular contraction and relaxation, starting with the lower legs, upper legs, hips, torso, shoulders and finally the arm and fist the energy can be transferred from muscle group to muscle group until it finally leaves your fist!

This won’t happen by chance though – only through training and practice can you learn to utilise the energy that you received via Newton’s third law of motion by pushing into the ground first. Without training this energy will just dissipate from your feet or half way up your legs and be wasted.  The harder you push into the ground the more energy you’ll get back (the harder you throw a ball at a wall the further and faster it comes back to you; the harder you push off the pool side the further and faster you’ll glide through the water).  Punching is only different because we are complex beings and we have to train to learn how to utilise that energy effectively.

The point of this blog post was not to explain the whole physics of punching but to give the scientific explanation (in layman’s terms) of why sensei is right when he says you must draw your punching power from the ground.  Do I make sense?




Bookmark and Share
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 2.0 UK: England & Wales License.

8 comments:

Charles James said...

Do you mean to take a solid stance with solid grounding to rely on that connection to generate power in the strike/punch?

Sue Wharton said...

Yes and that solid stance, gripping the floor with the feet, applies a downward push against the floor as you execute a punch such as a gyaku zuki.

John Coles said...

Now this is what my work is designed for. To inspire us to better understand techniques in practical terms so that we can improve them. I'm very pleased that my work inspired you to look at your techniques slightly differently. To understand the 'why' in addition to the 'how' which facilitates a better how. Can't wait to see what you make of the other two draft chapters I forwarded to you that related directly to striking and kicking techniques.

Sue Wharton said...

Thanks John, it's nice to be inspired! I'll get back to you when I've read the other chapters, thanks for trusting me with them ;-)

James Y said...

Yes in Wing Chun everything comes from the ground, this is how the one inch punch works, very hard to learn, its more about being relaxed aligned and routed.

Charles James said...

I asked Sue because I believe that power truly comes from the force as applied by mass and speed. The movement of mass, i.e. the direction it travels as speed and technique are applied gives us power but more important, mobility.

This is not saying you are wrong but as power is applied properly it is an instant of stability when the strike, etc. connects with the movement of the mass, the speed of the striking tool and such things as the penetration, i.e. the end of the technique has penetration into the target, etc.

To allow yourself to stop and rely heavily on rooting and the push against the floor removes, or so it seems, the mass behind the speed, etc.

What do you think?

Sue Wharton said...

James, oh to be able to do the one inch punch!

Charles, you are of course right about explaining the power of the punch through the application of mass and velocity. However I was merely trying to explain the importance of pushing down through the feet first and what happens when we do this. I did say at the end of the post that this wasn't a complete explanation of the physics of punching.

Charles James said...

Ahhh, yes, you did say that and it passed right through the old gray matter. Excellent and thanks for your patience in responding. :-)

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails